Book Club
  • Blog
  • Book Recommendations
  • Past Books
  • Blog
  • Book Recommendations
  • Past Books

Prehive Book Rant

9/7/2019

3 Comments

 

Posted by Madison

About the author of Tangerine: Christine Mangan was born in Detroit, raised in Long Island, New York, and North Carolina, and currently lives in Brooklyn. She received her PHD in English from University College Dublin, where her thesis focused on 18th century Gothic literature. Tangerine is her first novel. (From the publisher.) 

What are the effects of beginning a novel with an unreliable narrator? 

The chapters alternate between Alice and Lucy. What effect does this have? Could it have been told from one perspective and achieved the same feeling? I read one review that suggested it could have been told from Lucy's point of view alone, but I think the way it's written makes the book that much more disorienting. Alice and Lucy are clearly opposites, but their voices are sometimes written in a way that makes you double-check the name at the beginning of the chapter. The blending of this was intentional, I think, to make the reader question the reliability of both narrators.  One of the main questions is whether Alice’s paranoia is real or not. I have a feeling doctors of the time would call her hysterical. 

Tangier becomes a character in the novel. Youssef tells Lucy, “If you are looking for a place that makes sense, I feel I must provide this warning—you will be disappointed.”  In what way does Tangier enhance the plot? In many ways this reminds me of A Passage to India or Paul Bowles' The Sheltering Sky, both travel narratives that explore Other with a capital O by comparing Western and Eastern societies. 

The story is set in the 1950's at a time when it wasn’t acceptable for same-sex relationships or for women to exist much outside the kitchen. Based on era alone, the book begins with feelings of claustrophobia and shame. On top of this, we're transported to Tangier, a place even less progressive than the United States, during a time the French still ruled Morocco. Alice is terrified of Tangier and has panic attacks every time she thinks about leaving the house. Meanwhile, Lucy goes out on her own and explores the city (wearing trousers instead of a dress)! Both are outsiders but one of them embraces this, a nod to Youssef's distinction between tourist and traveler. 
​
3 Comments
Evan
9/7/2019 04:17:36 pm

That’s an interesting point about the relationship between the Other and traveling in foreign land.

I’ve had two incidents in which I successfully communicated with a local in a foreign country in their language. One time I informed a street vendor that my gf at the time wanted a ‘more cold’ bottled water. The other time I asked a baker for a chocolate croissant. Heavy stuff I know. But the stress I felt was real. There is something about not knowing the rules, the social customs, and speaking with someone who does. Only you can be wrong, only you can be rude. They belong and you don’t.

Reply
Katie
9/8/2019 10:50:46 am

Did someone say Brooklyn and Long Island in the same sentence? I have been searching all morning where on LI Christine Mangan is from! Oh my goodness the potential for our consensual but obsessive friendship that goes sour is high. I want all the lesbeian understones with this woman. I can't tell yet if I'm a Lucy or an Alice but honestly I take either. Christine if you are reading I'll be the Alice to your Lucy and let's go traveling ASAP.

Reply
Sean
9/14/2019 06:54:28 am

I disagree with the opinion of the reviewer Madison mentioned. I think perhaps the most interesting aspect of the book is the puzzle of trying to decipher which of the two narrators is giving us the real story. On one hand, Alice seems like the type whose own insecurities would skew her memories of her interactions with other people. On the other hand, Lucy is a compulsive liar and (possibly?) a psychopath.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    October 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019

Proudly powered by Weebly