Book Club
  • Blog
  • Book Recommendations
  • Past Books
  • Blog
  • Book Recommendations
  • Past Books

Rantin' with the Seandawg

9/14/2019

4 Comments

 
Hello, Tangerinos! I've got two things I'd like to open up for discussion:

Thing #1: Maybe it is because Rebecca is fresh in my memory, but I am noticing a lot of similarities between the two books. First of all, the prologue of Tangerine is reminiscent of the prologue of Rebecca. In both the narrator is recalling a place they no longer live that is ruined for them, and described with imagery of death and decay. Describing Tangiers: "For underneath the smell, underneath the comfort, there are flies buzzing, cockroaches stirring, starving cats gazing meanly, watching your every movement." Alice's personality mirrors that of the unnamed protagonist in Rebecca; they are both  extremely self-conscious and believe they don't fit in with those around them. They are simultaneously jealous and resentful of the more outgoing, confident people that surround them. In both stories the main character rushes into a marriage that takes them far away from their home. Alice's husband John seems to be a combination of Mr. De Winter and Jack (Rebecca's alcoholic cousin/lover). 

Thing #2: Now for my hot take: Lucy doesn't exist! More precisely, I think this is a Fight Club-type situation where Lucy is the manifestation of everything Alice wishes she could be. Some evidence: both Alice and Lucy use each others names to introduce themselves at different points. Also, when Alice is recovering from the car crash and asks about Lucy, her aunt Maude just says "You're confused, Alice, dear." (p.139). She had told Lucy "I want you to disappear and never come back" (p.135) before jumping in the car with Tom (I think Alice cut the brakes herself, btw). When she returns to her dorm room, it is completely empty; if Lucy did exist, knowing her personality and affinity with Alice, I don't think she would have left so easily...


That's all I've got for now, let me know what you think!
4 Comments
Evan
9/14/2019 08:11:00 am

I have definitely been thinking something similar along the lines of Lucy doesn't exist. The Aunt Maude thing made me think that she never had a roommate named Lucy, But John at times is in the same room with both of them and talking to both of them.

Reply
Sean
9/14/2019 08:16:50 am

I agree that we see Lucy and Alice interacting with others together, but I could see that being explained by an unreliable narrator. From the prologue: “Of course only the first bit is true-the rest I have simply imagined.”

Reply
Evan
9/14/2019 08:22:21 am

It's possible. Anything is at this point. If the Alice-Lucy complex conjured up a douche like John, I'm going to feel even worse for she/her/them.

Evan
9/14/2019 02:45:44 pm

The new hot theory is the lady who narrates the prologue is just imagining the whole thing. No one is real.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    October 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019

Proudly powered by Weebly